zeebad.blogg.se

Waves Tune produces a very sharp sounding result with very crisp tones, but it has a huge artifact towards the end of the sample. Even though many would say that synthetic vibrato is a gimmick, Waves and CrispyTuner both give you that feature at far lower prices. Melodyne lacks any sort of synthetic vibrato, which I feel is a shame for a plugin that costs this much. However, in practice, I got terrible results with that feature. It also offers a volume levelling feature to make quiet notes louder and vice versa, which none of the others have.

I think those two aspects of it are very valuable, and make it stand out. Melodyne does some sibilance detection and handles sibilant sounds differently when correcting the pitch, which I think helps make it sound more natural. In terms of usage outside of this benchmark, I found that the interface does a great job of grouping notes together in the way I would expect as a producer, meaning that there weren't any tiny sub-notes disconnected from the main singing. I think some of the dynamics have been lost here, and while it does sound the most human, I think it also degrades the quality of the recording a lot. My Thoughts​I think Melodyne produces the most "realistic"/natural results out of these four plugins, but it sounds somewhat muffled. I'll add my own thoughts, as well as some clarification, below. Results​Please hear for yourself how each plugin did with this. However, I'll acknowledge that this isn't a typical use case for these, so it's possible that this is a bit unfair towards plugins that are optimized for subtle changes.

This is a major enough change that we can easily hear artifacts and compare the results, so it makes it very interesting to compare them. I picked a vocal sample which was already in tune, from an Alicia Keys song, and pitched it 5 semitones up. So in order to test them in a way that would expose some weaknesses, I put them through a stress test. Methodology​Tuning out of pitch vocals is the most common use case for these plugins, but largely, they sound very similar when making minor adjustments. I posted this first on KVR and Reddit, but wanted to share here as well. So I tested several of them out, and I want to share the results for anyone else who's interested here. Hello all! I was wondering how similar current pitch correction plugins are to each other, and which ones have the highest quality.